Making history funny: is any historical topic off-limits?
Making history funny is a great way to “smuggle in facts”, says public historian Greg Jenner. But are there any subjects about which you just can’t make a joke? Speaking to the History Extra podcast, the Horrible Histories lead historian offers his take…
A hit children’s TV series – and now a summer film – Horrible Histories is beloved by many families for making history fun, all the while smuggling in true historical facts which delight and educate. Yet inevitably there’s a line, says the film’s lead historical advisor Greg Jenner, that cannot be crossed when telling children the stories of our past, such as particularly gory episodes or brutal battles.
But is there a more general line that must be respected when turning the past into parody? Or is all history up for grabs?
“There are, in theory, no subjects that are off-limits, because history is transgressive,” says Jenner. “The point of comedy is to find humour in things that are quite dark and macabre.”
“But there are definitely things that we have looked at on Horrible Histories and said ‘Well, how would we even start to do that?’ The Holocaust is certainly one of them. We looked at it because it’s such an important piece of history and of course Holocaust denial is such an insidious scourge that we have to combat. But there’s just no funny way in, really.
“I lost family in the Holocaust, and I felt very passionate that we should be looking at it and trying. But in the end there’s just no joke on it.
There are also elements, says Jenner – in the history of slavery and of empire, or Oliver Cromwell’s campaign in Ireland, for instance – in which there’s a need to be very careful around any jokes.
- History Extra Film and TV Awards, 2019
- Showering, teeth brushing and donning underwear: the strange history of our daily routine
- Period dramas should not be judged on historical accuracy, say historians
“[When looking at] the legacy of institutional violence against entire civilisations or entire continents by the British empire, or various global empires – the legacy is still there right now and you can’t be making jokes about it. If you do, you have got to be really careful.
“So in theory, no subject is off-limits, provided you can find the right joke. But that’s always the challenge and sometimes the right joke just doesn’t quite arrive.”
Greg Jenner is a public historian and advisor to film and TV. You can find him on Twitter @greg_jenner, and you can listen to the full interview on the History Extra podcast, available here. Horrible Histories: The Movie – Rotten Romans is out now in the UK and Ireland.
What do you think about the limits of historical comedy? Let us know your views on social media: Twitter @historyextra, or on Facebook
Authors
Elinor Evans is digital editor of HistoryExtra.com. She commissions and writes history articles for the website, and regularly interviews historians for the award-winning HistoryExtra podcast
Get exclusive access to Ruth Goodman’s six-week Academy course on Victorian Life, featuring two live Q&As + a book of your choice when you subscribe to BBC History Magazine
